Cherry Dummy vs Orthodontic: How to Choose a Dummy for Your Baby

It’s hard enough deciding whether or not you should offer your baby a dummy. Once you’ve made the decision, you then need to pick out a dummy. Where to start? There are so many different ones on the market! Ultimately, your baby will make the decision for you. Many babies have a definite preference when it comes to the dummy. Parents often seek the best dummy for their baby's needs, considering factors like material, nipple shape, and age suitability. There are two main decisions to start: orthodontic or cherry teat, and latex or silicone?

Types of Dummies

When it comes to choosing a dummy for your baby, the variety can be overwhelming. Here’s a quick guide to the most common types of dummies and their unique features:

• Orthodontic Dummies: Designed with a unique shape to promote healthy oral development, orthodontic dummies have a flat bottom and a rounded top. This design helps prevent dental issues as your baby grows.

• Cherry Teat Dummies: These dummies feature a round, cherry-shaped teat that closely resembles a mother’s nipple. Cherry teat dummies are often recommended for younger babies to avoid nipple confusion, especially for breastfed babies.

• Latex Dummies: Made from natural latex, these dummies are soft and flexible, providing a comfortable feel for your baby. Latex dummies are a popular choice for parents who prefer natural materials.

• Silicone Dummies: Constructed from soft, durable silicone, these dummies are easy to clean and maintain. Silicone dummies are known for their strength and longevity, making them a practical choice for many parents.

• Natural Rubber Dummies: For those seeking a non-toxic option, natural rubber dummies made from 100% natural rubber are an excellent choice. They are free from harmful chemicals and provide a safe, eco-friendly alternative.

Shape of the cherry teat

Dummy teats come in two shapes – round cherry shape and orthodontic. The orthodontic shapes have a rounded top and a flat bottom, so that the top of baby’s tongue rests flat against the bottom of the teat. Lactation consultants recommend a round cherry dummy teat, especially for younger babies. This is because it’s the same shape as a mother’s nipple, and doesn’t cause nipple confusion with breastfed babies. If you use an orthodontic nipple, it causes a very young baby to suck differently on the mother’s nipple and can hurt her and cause cracking and sore nipples. This can lead to problems with breastfeeding. Orthodontists, however, recommend an orthodontic shaped teat as it’s less likely to cause problems with teeth later on. So what’s the answer? Apparently, it’s to start with a round teat, and to switch to an orthodontic shaped teat around 6 months of age. Once your baby has a favourite type of dummy, however, this may be easier said than done. It seems that as long as baby is weaned off the dummy by around two years of age, there won’t be any adverse dental effects, no matter what shaped teat you use.

Latex or silicone dummies

The next choice is between the materials the teats are made from. You have a choice between latex and silicone teats. Silicone teats are a man-made, soft yet strong material. It's easy to clean, and doesn't retain smells or flavours. The silicone used in baby dummies is usually medical grade silicone. While silicone doesn't tear like latex under the pressure of sharp little baby teeth, those same teeth may be able to bite chunks out of a silicone teat. It's important to examine the dummy before each use, and replace it as soon as you see any signs of wear. You should replace a dummy every six to eight weeks in any case.

Latex is a natural material, made from the sap of the Hevea Brasiliensis (rubber) tree. Latex is more flexible than silicone, and it feels softer in baby's mouth. However, because it's softer, they can sometimes wear out faster and once baby develops teeth they may be able to tear it more easily than silicone.

Latex can also have a strong taste at first. Boiling the dummy in milk before first use will take that strong taste away. Some rubber and latex products are manufactured using nitrosamines. There is some evidence that nitrosamines are carcinogenic, so look for latex teats that are nitrosamine free. They're easy to find, and if you're not sure, ask the manufacturer. Some babies can have allergies to latex. If there's a history of latex allergies in the family, you're probably better off choosing a silicone teat.

Dummy Size

Choose a dummy that is the right size for your baby's age. It's usually straightforward - teats get bigger for older babies as their mouths get bigger. Most dummies are available in two options – under six months and over six months.

Orthodontic dummies style

Once you’ve worked out which teat to choose, have a look at the rest of the dummy. Using a dummy chain can help prevent lost dummies, but it is important to ensure it meets safety standards to avoid potential choking hazards. The dummy shield should have holes in it. This helps to prevent skin rashes around baby’s mouth. More importantly, in the very unlikely event that the dummy should become lodged in baby’s mouth, the holes allow baby to breathe. The shield should be wider than 3.5cms so that your baby can’t put the whole thing in her mouth. All dummies that meet Australian standards will have these holes and the correct size shield. It’s also a good idea to look for a dummy that’s made from one piece of plastic, as it’s less likely to come apart and become a choking hazard. You can also get latex dummies that are moulded entirely from one piece, including the teat. Look for dummies that are BPA free and phthalate free, too.

Safety Features

Ensuring your baby’s safety is paramount when selecting a dummy. Here are some key safety features to look for:

• One-Piece Design: A dummy with a one-piece design reduces the risk of parts breaking off and becoming a choking hazard. This design is more durable and safer for your baby.

• Large, Soft Shield: The shield should be large enough to prevent the dummy from entering your baby’s mouth too far. A soft shield with ventilation holes allows for airflow, preventing skin irritation and the buildup of bacteria.

• Secure Attachment System: Ensure the dummy has a secure attachment system to prevent it from coming loose. This helps keep the dummy in place and reduces the risk of it falling and getting dirty.

• Non-Toxic Materials: Look for dummies made from BPA-free and phthalate-free materials. These non-toxic options are safer for your baby and reduce the risk of exposure to harmful chemicals.

Choosing the Right Dummy

Selecting the right dummy for your baby can be a daunting task. Here are some tips to help you make the best choice:

• Consider Your Baby’s Age and Size: Dummies come in different sizes to match your baby’s age and mouth size. Ensure you choose a dummy that is appropriate for your baby’s developmental stage.

• Think About Your Baby’s Preferences: Babies can be particular about the shape and material of their dummies. It might take some trial and error to find the one your baby prefers, whether it’s a cherry dummy or an orthodontic dummy.

• Look for Safety Features: Prioritize dummies with essential safety features like a one-piece design, large shield, and ventilation holes. These features help ensure your baby’s safety and comfort.

• Check the Material: Opt for dummies made from non-toxic materials such as natural rubber or medical-grade silicone. These materials are safe for your baby and easy to clean.

• Read Reviews: Other parents’ experiences can be invaluable. Check reviews to see what others think about the dummies you’re considering. This can help you make a more informed decision.

Sterilising the dummy

For babies younger than six months, you'll need to be able to sterilize the dummy. Check that the dummy you buy can be sterilized the way you prefer. Babies older than six months have better immunity, so washing in warm soapy water is enough.

Dummy chain clip

Although it’s a nuisance when your baby drops the dummy into the dirt, be aware that dummy chains can be dangerous. If you use one, make sure that it meets Australian standards. If it’s too long, it could catch around a baby's neck and become a choking hazard. You may find that you need to offer your baby a few different types of dummies before you find one that she likes. Once you find the perfect dummy, make sure to get extras. There’s nothing worse than a meltdown in the middle of the night when the dummy has disappeared!

Want to see what sort of dummies are available? Jump on over to Hello Charlie and check out our range of dummies and pacifiers.

Image: Hevea

Tips for Using Dummies

Using a dummy can be a great way to soothe your baby, but it’s important to use it correctly. Here are some tips for safe and effective dummy use:

• Introduce the Dummy at the Right Time: If you’re breastfeeding, wait until your baby is at least 4-6 weeks old before introducing a dummy. This helps avoid nipple confusion and ensures breastfeeding is well-established.

• Use the Dummy Consistently: Consistent use can help your baby get used to the dummy. However, avoid using it as a substitute for feeding or comfort from you.

• Clean the Dummy Regularly: Keep the dummy clean to prevent the buildup of bacteria. For babies under six months, sterilize the dummy regularly. For older babies, washing with warm soapy water is sufficient.

• Avoid Using the Dummy as a Substitute for Breastfeeding: Use the dummy as a supplement to breastfeeding, not a replacement. This ensures your baby gets the necessary nutrition and comfort from breastfeeding.

• Be Aware of the Risks: Understand the potential risks associated with dummy use, such as nipple confusion and choking hazards. Always supervise your baby when using a dummy and check it regularly for signs of wear and tear.

By following these tips and choosing the right dummy, you can ensure your baby’s comfort and safety.

Image: Hevea